GaramChai.com >> Book >> Section 2
Finances for Immigrants
In
recent times, aided by the demand for a mobile global workforce,
hordes of young professionals from India moved to the US,
Europe and other western lands in search of opportunities
and wealth. Their quest was aided by the strong demand from
western nations that were experiencing unprecedented growth.
The real motivator was the dynamics of exchange rate differences
between the Indian rupee and other currencies, making migration
abroad especially attractive. For instance, a budding professional
in India who would have to save for about two years to buy
a snazzy motorcycle back home could save enough in a year
to buy a compact car.
For
people from developing nations like India, the combination
of exchange rate differences and Purchasing Power Parity
(PPP) makes a migration to a western country especially
attractive. PPP theory states that exchange rates between
currencies are in equilibrium when their purchasing power
is the same in each of the two countries. Take for example
the Big Mac sold by Mc Donald’s in 116 countries around
the world making it a truly global consumer product. Since
1986, the Economist magazine has tracked the price of the
Big Mac around the world, calling it the “Big Mac Index”.
To the Indian reader, contemplating a move to a foreign
country, a study of PPP and the Big Mac Index will give
an indication of the amount one would have to spend in order
to maintain a similar “standard of living” in the new environment.
What this also means is that a reader will get a more accurate
idea on the earning and saving potential in different countries.
The percentage of salary saved, say ten percent of one’s
salary will have a greater bang for the buck when saved
in the US than in India since a US dollar is stronger than
a rupee.
In
this section of the book, we will look at various aspects
of a person’s financial life in the US including savings,
taxes, entrepreneurship and credit reporting. While working
and earning money in the US, Indian professionals also need
to be considering the various savings options available
to them. They need to be aware of the credit-tracking and
scoring mechanism in the US that will enable them not only
to get loans and credit but will also help them operate
bank accounts and manage other financial transactions. India
follows the British financial model and many Indians with
bank accounts are comfortable in the basics of financial
management, hence the transition to the US financial system
is not drastic. Finance, banking and investing in America
is highly regulated and oriented towards safeguarding the
interests of an investor. Investors are assured of basic
financial stability. However, they need to be aware of the
ground rules in order to find one’s way around the maze.
Snapshot
of United States Economy (Extract
from CIA Factbook)
Overview: |
The
US has the largest and most technologically powerful
economy in the world, with a per capita GDP of $36,200.
In this market-oriented economy, private individuals
and business firms make most of the decisions, and
government buys needed goods and services predominantly
in the private marketplace. US business firms enjoy
considerably greater flexibility than their counterparts
in Western Europe and Japan in decisions to expand
capital plant, lay off surplus workers, and develop
new products. At the same time, they face higher barriers
to entry in their rivals' home markets than the barriers
to entry of foreign firms in US markets. US firms
are at or near the forefront in technological advances,
especially in computers and in medical, aerospace,
and military equipment, although their advantage has
narrowed since the end of World War II. The onrush
of technology largely explains the gradual development
of a "two-tier labor market" in which those
at the bottom lack the education and the professional/technical
skills of those at the top and, more and more, fail
to get comparable pay raises, health insurance coverage,
and other benefits. Since 1975, practically all the
gains in household income have gone to the top 20%
of households. The years 1994-2000 witnessed solid
increases in real output, low inflation rates, and
a drop in unemployment to below 5%. Long-term problems
include inadequate investment in economic infrastructure,
rapidly rising medical costs of an aging population,
sizable trade deficits, and stagnation of family income
in the lower economic groups. Growth weakened in the
fourth quarter of 2000; growth for the year 2001 almost
certainly will be substantially lower than the strong
5% of 2000. The outlook for 2001 is further clouded
by the continued economic problems of Japan, Russia,
Indonesia, Brazil, and many other countries. |
GDP: |
Purchasing power parity - $9.963 trillion (2000 est.) |
GDP - real growth rate: |
5%
(2000 est.) |
GDP
- per capita: |
Purchasing power parity - $36,200 (2000 est.) |
Inflation rate (consumer prices): |
3.4% (2000) |
Labor force: |
140.9 million (includes unemployed) (2000) |
Labor
force |
Managerial and professional 30.2%, technical, sales
and administrative Support 29.2%, services 13.5%,
manufacturing, mining, transportation, and crafts
24.6%, farming, forestry, and fishing 2.5% (2000)
note: figures exclude the unemployed |
Budget: |
Revenues: $1.828 trillion
expenditures: $1.703 trillion, including
capital expenditures of $NA (1999) |
Industries: |
Leading industrial power in the world, highly diversified
and technologically advanced; petroleum, steel, motor
vehicles, aerospace, telecommunications, chemicals,
electronics, food processing, consumer goods, lumber,
mining |
Agriculture
- products: |
Wheat, other grains, corn, fruits, vegetables, cotton;
beef, pork, poultry, dairy products; forest products;
fish |
Exports: |
$776 billion (f.o.b., 2000 est.) |
Imports: |
$1.223 trillion (f.o.b., 2000 est.) |
Debt
- external: |
$862 billion (1995 est.) |
Currency: |
US
dollar (USD) |
Exchange
rates: |
US
dollar – Rupees 47.83 (December 2001) |
Earning
potential in the US
One
of the most common questions I am asked in India, when people
realize that I happen to be an NRI living and working in
the US, is about my earnings. How much do I make? I don’t
know about anyone else, but I am extremely squeamish about
my earnings and rarely like to discuss it with most people.
Jaws drop when people in India find that even relatively
inexperienced software professional in the US make a few
thousand dollars a month (after taxes). A quick mental arithmetic
ensues, converting the figure into Rupees. At that point,
it is futile to even explain the concept of cost of living,
or even the fact that an apartment rent alone runs hundreds
of dollars a month, for that matter even a burger or coke
costs a few dollars (Big Mac Index). It is hard to point
out the fact that the key is not what one earns but what
one is able to comfortably save, maintaining a standard
of living that commensurates with local norms.
The
salary one receives in the US could depend on a number of
factors like one’s marketability, demand and supply (of
the skillset) at the time of hiring, the region, city state
of work, the specialization of one’s job, skills and knowledgebase.
The kind of employer one works for, nature of industry,
length of one’s tenure and experience also play a role.
The American free market system extends to jobs and wages;
hence, no two people with similar backgrounds, experiences
and qualifications can expect the same salary or wages.
For instance, working for a large corporation may not be
highly paying but the job stability and the number of perks
that comes with the job may make it worthwhile. By the same
token, risks and rewards go hand in hand. Working for a
small startup with limited funding and stock options may
be highly risky, but if the company takes off, so do the
employees fortunes. Sometimes, as thousands of dot.comers
found to their dismay, the risks of working for small companies
may be too real to ignore. The bottomline: At an early stage
in one’s career, people can afford to take on bigger risks
without worrying about the consequences but as years go
by, tolerance to risk may be mitigated by the need for security
and stability, reflecting on the pay package.
At the
risk of sounding a bit pessimistic, I want to point out
the fact that cultural background and communication skills
of individuals also play an important role in determining
one’s marketability and earning potential. There are certain
jobs and careers where communications play a greater role.
For example in the field of marketing or account management,
one needs to be able to market one’s vision and the services
to people from different strata of the society. A stellar
marketing guru from India who is transplanted to the US
will probably require some time in understanding the cultural
and social nuances before being fully productive. Other
aspects of culture include the accent of one’s spoken communication
and usage of English, which also play a role in landing
and keeping a job. It can sometimes be difficult, if not
impossible, for foreigners who have spent a good part of
their life in India to prove to prospective employers that
they are on par with their peers in the American job market.
To be
fair to the American system, excellence, regardless of race
or ethnic background is well rewarded and Indians do succeed
in myriad vocations in the US. It also helps that the legal
system and affirmative action by the government ensures
that employers cannot discriminate against employees on
the basis of race, color, religion, sex or national origin,
and requires affirmative action to ensure equal employment
opportunity without regard to those factors.
There
are also nuances involving professional certifications and
licensing that people in different professions need to be
aware of. For example, CA (Chartered Accountants) from India
might need to clear the certification exams before they
are granted a CPA (Certified Public Accountants) status.
Similarly, doctors, lawyers, bankers and even teachers from
India need to clear American certifications before they
are allowed to pursue a career. Information Technology is
perhaps the most liberal field when it comes to accepting
foreigners without requiring additional certifications.
U.S.
Bureau of Labor Statistics studies and tabulates data and
statistics on the labor market across the country. They
also publish periodic reports on unemployment, job markets,
cost of living and studies on professional and career trends.
A sampling of hourly rates for different occupations extracted
from the official US Bureau of Labor data is appended below.
This data pertains to the national averages and regional
variations may be quite drastic. For example the software
engineer working for a Californian startup will draw a much
higher salary (adjusted for cost of living) than his peer
working for a small company in Kentucky. The data in the
table is intended to act as a reference and will help the
reader get a ballpark estimate of salary and wage trends
in the US. Most fulltime employees in the US work an average
of five days a week, eight hours a day. This translates
to an average of 2080 hours a year, a figure generally used
to compute annual salaries. By this estimate, a Bank Teller
who earns about $9.22/hour will have an approximate annual
salary of $ 19,177.
Table
1: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics (1999)
Occupation
|
Hourly
Rate
|
White collar occupations
|
$18.78
|
Engineers, architects, and surveyors
|
$29.36
|
Aerospace engineers
|
$32.75
|
Electrical and electronic engineers
|
$32.10
|
Mechanical engineers
|
$24.89
|
Computer systems analysts and scientists
|
$28.49
|
Physicists and astronomers
|
$37.84
|
Chemists, exc. Biochemists
|
$29.16
|
Geologists and geodesists
|
$28.27
|
Biological and life scientists
|
$23.03
|
Physicians
|
$63.07
|
Dentists
|
$40.34
|
Physical therapists
|
$23.84
|
Professors, college and university
|
$35.61
|
Pre-kindergarten and kindergarten teachers, exc.
postsecondary
|
$16.33
|
Secondary school teachers, exc. Postsecondary
|
$28.70
|
Economists
|
$28.14
|
Lawyers
|
$38.30
|
Photographers
|
$18.26
|
Editors and reporters
|
$24.30
|
Licensed practical nurses
|
$13.40
|
Administrators and officials, public administration
|
$26.87
|
Managers, marketing, advertising, and public relations
|
$38.03
|
Accountants and auditors
|
$21.14
|
Management analysts
|
$25.03
|
Sales engineers
|
$30.60
|
Sales occupations, other business services
|
$19.31
|
Cashiers
|
$7.96
|
Supervisors, general office
|
$16.35
|
Secretaries
|
$13.55
|
Stenographers
|
$13.73
|
Receptionists
|
$9.74
|
Order clerks
|
$12.37
|
Messengers
|
$8.70
|
Bank tellers
|
$9.22
|
Data-entry keyers
|
$10.55
|
Automobile mechanics
|
$15.26
|
Aircraft engine mechanics
|
$21.19
|
Electronic repairers, communications and industrial
equipment
|
$18.61
|
Telephone installers and repairers
|
$18.21
|
Carpenters
|
$17.25
|
Electricians
|
$19.12
|
Machine operators, assemblers, and inspectors
|
$11.41
|
Truck drivers
|
$12.72
|
Bus drivers
|
$12.38
|
Marine engineers
|
$15.56
|
Cooks
|
$8.24
|
Guards and police, exc. Public service
|
$8.89
|
Police and detectives, public service
|
$20.25
|
Firefighting occupations
|
$16.13
|
Saving
for a rainy day
One
of the main reasons why people migrate to foreign lands
is to increase the earnings, savings and consequently increase
one’s net wealth. For Indians moving abroad, the initial
few years are spent chasing the “American Dream” acquiring
a car, furniture, paraphernalia, and in traveling around
the country. Of course, the first few years are also spent
in saving and helping family and folks back home. Most of
us from middle class backgrounds in India take great pride
in the sense of belonging and attachment we have towards
our families. Helping parents move into a nice flat or getting
a sister married is almost de rigueur. Regardless of one’s
financial situation, it takes a few years to lay a sound
foundation and to build a base for a secure future.
After
a spending few years abroad, many of us start realizing
the duality of the lives we are trying to lead. It is at
such a point that we decide if we are going to be here “for
a while”, we might start planning for a secure financial
future. Although saving for a rainy day is second nature
to most Indians, we get sucked into the credit card and
car-loan culture, initially because of the need to acquire
white goods, and subsequently to keep up with the Jains.
Some of the best technical minds may not be really good
when it comes to financial management. Many of us feel that
working towards a secure financial future means stashing
away a sum of money in the bank every month. Some work on
investing in the stock market or other investments that
may be the flavor of the day. An article of mine on
“lessons in stock market economics is attached)
Financial
planning and working towards a secure future involves a
taking a long-term holistic view of one’s goals and financial
targets. Working professionals in India are involuntarily
included their company’s retirement fund and PPF (Public
Provided Fund) that they and their employers contribute
to. Most of the “career track” professionals are also assured
of a gratuity or pension when they retire. This concept
is absent in the US. Most companies do not even have
a formal ‘retirement plan’ other than the common 401-Ks,
now made infamous by the crash of Enron. Employees working
for the recently bankrupt Enron Corporation (more about
it later in the book) lost their life’s savings including
retirement funds because they were highly vested in the
company’s stock and when the stock plummeted, so did their
fortunes. For Indian professionals in the US, it is especially
important to think about their financial future because
unlike their peers back home, they might have a bright earning
potential but no security net or retirement funds to speak
of.
The
US government, realizing the need to provide for its ageing
population, encourages long-term savings in many ways. After
the Enron crash, the government is going to become more
involved in regulating the retirement funds and savings
to ensure that people are not closely tied to their company’s
fortunes (more than they should really be). The government
does not discriminate against foreigners when it comes to
tax breaks, incentives and retirement savings. However,
the onus is still on individuals to plan for their financial
futures. Individuals need to do a tremendous amount of research
and due diligence in order to seek the best options available.
They must also endeavour to educate themselves about all
the incentives, tax brakes and tools of investments available
to them. I have been trying to research some of the American
investment avenues available to Non Resident Indians like
myself. Some of them include:
Social
Security: Almost everyone working in the US pays a part
of his/her salary towards a social security fund set up
and managed by the Social Security Administration (a wing
of the Federal government). The percentage of salary deduction
varies, but is generally between six to eight percent. Employers
are also required to contribute an equal amount towards
social security. The federal government pools this amount
collected from individuals (and companies) and holds it
in a large fund. People generally become eligible to receive
social security benefits when they turn 59, or in some cases,
if they lose the ability to earn a living or become disabled.
Even foreigners are required to contribute to the social
security fund and are eligible to get the benefits. The
only catch is that a person becomes eligible to get social
security benefits only if they contribute into the system
for at least ten years. Many Indians working in the US on
H1 visa’s are only eligible to live and work for six years
after which they must return back and will not be eligible
to receive the social security benefits.
There
is also a lot of debate going on over the future of social
security system in the US. People are starting to doubt
if the fund, that is dwindling, will be available to them
when they are ready to retire in fifteen or twenty years.
This is because the baby boomers, a large percent of current
population, are starting to age and are becoming eligible
for social security benefits. The current contribution into
the social security fund is less than the outflow. Hence,
young workers and taxpayers are doubtful if they will receive
any benefits from the fund when they are ready to retire
decades from now.
Retirement
Savings: Working professional in America contribute
a part of their salary towards retirement saving plans like
401-K, IRAs (Individual Retirement Accounts) etc. Companies
also encourage employees to save by opening an account for
them and allow employees to ‘rollover’ their accounts in
case they switch jobs. Some employers also match a small
percent of contributions that their employees make. 401-K
accounts are easy to set-up and manage. They can be set
up with almost any financial institution like a bank, broker
or savings fund. One can contribute any amount (up to about
10 percent) of one’s pre-tax salary into the account and
one need not pay any tax on contributions made. The catch
is that one cannot withdraw from the account until one retires,
generally after turning 58. Withdrawals from a 401-K account
are penalized heavily and there is little incentive to withdraw
prematurely. However, people are allowed to take a loan
against their 401-K savings, but even this is highly regulated.
A loan is generally allowed only for specific reasons like
child’s education, down payment on a house etc.
The
Enron saga has lead to a lot of concern over the stability
of individual 401 K accounts. Despite this, individual retirement
savings and tax deferred investments are a really powerful
investment vehicle.
Educational
savings: People are allowed to save a part of the pre-tax
dollars they earn by contributing into special saving accounts,
also called Roth IRAs. This is a special tax incentive given
to individuals who want to save for their children’s education.
The amount can be withdrawn (without any penalty) to pay
for any educational expense. The government, realizing the
importance of education also offers a number of tax incentives
and breaks to those spending on education.
Buying
a House: Another popular form of tax benefiting investment
in the US is to buy a house. There are two strong reasons
that motivate people to buy houses. One reason is the appreciation
in property and savings experienced by property owners who
live in a house for a while (and save on rent). Another
motivation is the tax break, given to homeowners. People
take mortgages (loans) to buy houses and subsequently make
monthly payments. There are two components of the monthly
payment the principal and the interest. The interest paid
towards mortgage is ‘tax deductible’, i.e. one can reduce
the amount from one’s gross earnings and pay a lesser tax.
Foreigners,
even those on H1 visas are not precluded from buying property
in the US. A number of Indians here on a H1 visas have invested
in houses. The only caveat is that buying a house restricts
one’s mobility since it is not easy to sell a house and
move out overnight. There are a number of costs involved
in buying a house and it is generally assumed that the costs
will be amortised over a period of time. One loses all the
benefits (of buying a house) if one were to sell it within
a year or two, unless the property appreciates substantially.
Stocks,
bonds and mutual funds: Historically, returns on stocks
have been greater than returns on most other forms of investments.
Investing in stocks can be complex: there are thousands
of companies in hundreds of sectors to choose from. Of course,
one can also opt to invest in a “basket of stocks” by investing
in mutual funds. Stocks are not for the faint-hearted or
anyone who might need an element of liquidity. Attached
to this section is an earlier article of mine on the stock
market crash. Financial advisors generally suggest investing
in stocks as a means to generate aggressive returns, especially
for those with a long-term perspective. With the advent
of Internet and online trading, it is extremely convenient
to trade US stocks from anywhere. Opening a stock/brokerage
account in the US is as simple as opening a bank account.
The
focus of most people emigrating from India is to magnify
the earning potential. Saving a percentage of one’s earnings
is the real key to building net worth. NRIs in the US are
realizing that prudent investment of one’s savings can help
magnify it in the long run. Saving for the long term requires
a lot of thought, planning and research, and a dollar saved
and prudently invested could go a long way. With the varied
avenues for investment available, saving and investing for
the future can also be an interesting leisure pursuit.
An important
aspect of savings is tax planning. Like most countries in
the world, America levies Income taxes on all residents
(including foreigners) who earn a living. The government
also encourages people to save for the future by giving
tax breaks and incentives, therefore it is imperative for
people to be aware of the tax code and the different incentives
in the tax code. Individuals are also made aware of the
tax code and details regarding income taxes because it is
their responsibility to file a tax return every year. In
the next section, we will look at the intricacies involved
in individual income taxes.
Income Tax
Living
and working in the US, the inevitability of Benjamin Franklin’s
oft repeated quote "in life, nothing is certain
but death and taxes" does not elude me. The significance
of taxes really hits home during March and April when a
tax mania sweeps across the country. As the April 15th deadline
for filing taxes approaches people scramble to find the
required forms, software and/or tax practitioners. Uncle
Sam’s reach extends to everyone living and making money
in the US, including NRIs, and those on H1 Visas.
The
US Government, like most governments around the world, levies
a tax on income earned by people living and earning there.
The tax collection process has been tuned into a well-oiled
machinery. In the five years that I have spent in the US,
I have not ceased to be amazed at the efficiency with which
the Internal Revenue System (IRS) goes about enforcing the
tax code. People are acutely aware of their fiscal obligation
towards the Government, if only for the lure of ‘refunds’
that may be due to them. Every year IRS embarks on a major
PR campaign to educate and inform the public of their fiscal
responsibility.
Income
taxes in the US are of different kinds. Almost everyone
has to pay the federal (central) income taxes. Depending
on where one lives, state, county and city taxes will also
apply. Along with the taxes, other surcharges like Social
Security, Medicare etc are added to one’s federal tax and
an average person will end up seeing almost 30 percent of
the earnings going to Uncle Sam. Most of the income tax
is deducted at source. Employers deduct a percentage of
the salary that is due to the various government bodies
before disbursing the net amount to the employee. At the
end of every year, it is the responsibility of the taxpayer
to compute the actual tax that was due. If an excess amount
was withheld, the taxpayer will be eligible for a refund,
otherwise, he will have to pay the residual taxes.
Apart
from their regular income, most people will have other incomes
in the form bank interest and dividends, profits and losses
from trading stocks etc. These incomes are generally added
to the gross income on which taxes are due. The government
gives tax breaks for medical expenses, donations to charities,
savings for retirement, interest on home-loan mortgages.
Most of the income and deductions are tracked by the banks
and financial institutions, which report them to IRS. People
generally work on their tax filing forms during weekends
preceding the April deadline. There are a number of tax
software packages available that speed up the process of
computation, filling forms and can even be used to electronically
file the tax returns to the IRS.
With
huge databases and computer systems developed decades ago,
IRS is able to track and process income tax filings with
amazing efficiency. In spite of what the media says, the
system works. Their systems are constantly being updated
and most individual tax filers are able (and encouraged)
to file their taxes electronically. State governments have
also jumped on to the electronic bandwagon and allow for
income tax filings over the Web. I generally prefer to electronically
file my state and federal taxes towards the end of February
and receive my tax refund in my bank account in about ten
days.
What
happens if you do not file taxes? Most people do not even
want to imagine the consequences. Fear of IRS has reached
mythical proportions and is a butt of Talk Show jokes. One
thing is certain, big brother is watching. Case in point,
along with a few friends, I ‘founded’ a Limited Liability
Company in Colorado sometime last year. We went ahead and
got a tax ID because it was required for us to open a corporate
bank account. During January, along with all my other tax
documents, I received a letter from IRS reminding me to
file the tax returns for the company by April 16th! The
‘archaic’ IRS system was smart enough to realize that a
new company was operating in Colorado and that it had to
file its tax returns along with every one else.
Indians
coming to the US for the first time are initially bewildered
by Income Taxes – Federal, State, County, Social Security
and Medicare taxes – that are withdrawn from their paychecks.
They soon realize that there is a method in the madness
and find that employers unobtrusively withdraw the taxes
from their paychecks. It is the responsibility of every
employer in the US to automatically deduct the taxes and
send them to the government.
The
flip side of all this is that the government is able to
generate a lot of money. Almost 30 to 35 percent of earnings
- from millions of its citizens and foreign workers add
up to trillions of dollars. That money is used to build
roads, for education, public services, libraries and to
provide good clean water and basic amenities to everyone.
Credit Tracking and History
Banking
and financial systems in the US are quite different from
that in India. People in India, even those with respectable
jobs, working for reputable organizations find the prospect
of going to a banker quite daunting. It is hard to imagine
walking into a bank and asking for a credit card or car
loan. Most people would probably have to use some ‘contacts’
i.e. call up an uncle or cousin who knows someone remotely
associated with a bank or financial institution. Of course,
there is a method in the madness. Banks, like all prudent
financial institutions like to safeguard their investments.
The bank manager or loan officer relies on the referral
you provide her. One can argue that computerization of branches
and the advent of a streamlined accounting system, will
lead to transparency within the Indian banking industry.
The
system is quite different in the US where all financial
transactions between individuals and banks are tracked,
monitored and recorded. This record is known as a “credit
history”, and helps financial institutions take decisions
on the creditworthiness of prospective customers. It also
helps that there is a common key in the form of Social Security
Number (SSN) that is used in credit tracking.
Every
person in the US, including legal aliens on H1 work visas
is given an SSN or Tax ID, which is a nine-digit number.
The SSN is thus a unique identifier and used by a number
of institutions including Internal Revenue Service (IRS),
the Federal Income Tax tracking body, to track the tax compliance
of every resident. The SSN is used by the three major credit
rating agencies in the US - Equifax, Experian and Trans
Union to uniquely identify, record and report every
individual’s financial transaction including debts, credits,
bankruptcies, loans, mortgages, court decisions etc. Complex
IT systems, networks and powerful mainframes are constantly
at work churning through millions of transactions in order
to provide a meaningful analysis and decision making tool
that almost every banker and financial decision maker in
the US uses. All the three credit rating agencies in the
US constantly share data between their systems to get them
to be in sync.
The
process of gathering the data is quite straightforward.
When a person, say Mr. Shetty moves to the US and acquires
a SSN, among the first things he does is to open a bank
account. If he applies for a credit card, the banker checks
for his credit report, which obviously doesn’t exist. At
this point, the banker might reject the application citing
a lack of credit history. However, the story does not end
there. Since the reporting agency’s system does not find
an entry for the SSN being keyed on, it creates a new record
for that person with the SSN as the unique identifier. The
enquiry is thus “recorded” in the agency’s system. As Mr.
Shetty goes on with his life, applying for a car loan or
another credit card or store charge card, every new interaction
that he has with a financial institution gets recorded.
A history of all such transactions, recorded by the systems
managed by these credit bureaus can be summarized and is
given to anyone authorised to look it up. Even individuals
have a right to acquire a copy of their credit report and
are encouraged to do so periodically.
Most
Americans start their financial affairs early in life and
their transactions get recorded over a period of time. They
are quite paranoid about maintaining a good “credit history”
since a clean report is a harbinger to getting favorable
rates of interest when applying for credit cards, loans
and mortgages. Of course, most Americans live on credit
and people sometimes default on credit card payments or
other loans, which immediately reflects in a negative credit
score.
Indian
professionals, landing in the US initially find it extremely
difficult to establish a financial history. The first time
a foreigner walk into a US bank or financial institution,
she has to try extra hard to convince the banker that the
lack of credit history does not mean that she is not willing
to be financially prudent. Lots of traditional banks are
wary of opening accounts for a people without any credit
history. Hence, people new to the country find it easier
to join a “credit unions”. A credit union is a "non-profit
financial cooperative." When you join a credit union,
you become a member and part owner of the credit union.
The credit union’s only goal is to satisfy its members—with
lower loan rates, higher deposit rates and better service
than most any bank you’re likely to find. Members of any
given credit union generally share a common bond. For example,
many large employers have their own credit unions where
only employees can join. Some employers also provide
referral to banks, brokerage and financial institutions.
Until
this point, we have looked at the various aspects pertaining
to financial affairs of individuals. We looked at the savings,
financial planning, taxes, banking and earning potential
of individuals working in the US. The “American Dream”, being rich and successful is extremely contagious, and even
Indians who move to the US dream of making it big, either
in their chosen careers or by venturing into entrepreneurship.
During the dot.com and Internet boom, even Indians succeeded
in generating a few killer applications and were lucky enough
to walk away with astronomical sums of money. In the next
section, we will look at Indians as entrepreneurs in the
US.
Entrepreneurship
in America
The
list of successful Indians who have made it big in corporate
America reads like a who’s who of the business world. Indians
have climbed to the top of Fortune five hundred corporations
like Citicorp and US Air, founded multi-billion dollar companies
like I2 and have been extremely successful in most endeavors.
The word entrepreneur, to most of us, conjures visions of
a person who runs his own enterprise, bringing together
resources like land, labour, capital and his entrepreneurial
skills, in the process amassing wealth. Being an entrepreneur
does not contradict the idea of professionalism, but is
increasingly being seen as an extension of it.
Most
Indians, especially those from middle-class backgrounds
are quite risk-averse, especially when it comes to business
and ventures. We are led to believe that the only way to
achieve steady success in life is by studying hard, focusing
on education and later excelling in our chosen vocations
or careers. The American Dream contradicts this notion.
It is every American’s dream to strike gold by thinking
of an ‘All American’ product, idea or service, selling out
and making millions.
There
are thousands of people of Indian origin in the US who are
entrepreneurs in the conventional sense. They run gas stations
(petrol bunks), motels, restaurants, Indian bazaars and
other small businesses. Many of them are from the highly
industrious Gujarati community who came to the US during
the seventies and early eighties after they were uprooted
from their homes by African dictators. They were granted
asylum in the US, UK and other countries and decided to
settle here. As per one research report, over 70 percent
of motels in the US are owned by Patels.
Interestingly,
even the government realizing the need for entrepreneurship
and job creation, has a special provision in the immigration
rules to provide green cards to foreigners who invest a
specified sum of money (currently about a million dollars)
and help create at least ten jobs in America.
Many
Indians, who came to the US as H1-techies during the boom
of the nineties, also caught the entrepreneurial bug. Of
course, the runaway success of an Indian Stanford graduate,
Sabeer Bhatia, who sold his company to Microsoft for a whooping
450 million dollars, really captured the imagination of
a whole generation. He not only became in instant celebrity
but also gave inspiration to thousands who tried to emulate
his accomplishment, many of them successfully. The dot.com
world may be littered with the debris of could-have-been’s
but there are scores of Indians who cashed out in time –
either through foresight or by sheer luck – and will tell
their stories for years to come.
Indians
from technical backgrounds were instrumental in spawning
a whole array of business ideas ranging from mundane body
shops to hi-tech fibre-optic, wireless and supply-chain
systems. The list of successful Indians who have made it
big in corporate America reads like a who’s who of the business
world. On one hand we have the likes of Vinod Khosla (founder
Sun Microsystems), Sanjiv Sidhu (I2) and Pradeep Sindhu
(Juniper), on the other hand, we have the troves of friendly-neighbourhood
body-shoppers. And of course a whole range of entrepreneurs
in between.
During
the early years of the tech boom, one of the most popular
‘business ideas’ was to start a technical consulting company.
All one had to do was to place an advert in the local newspapers
in Bangalore or Hyderabad, sift through the hundreds of
resumes that would pour in and pick up the most promising
candidates, and sponsor their H1 visa. Once the candidates
landed in the US, hi-tech companies, hungry for bodies would
grab them like hot cakes. The middleman would keep his cut
of billing rate and go scouting for more bodies to “import”.
There were little or no barriers to entry in this business
and hundreds of thousands of body-shops mushroomed in the
US. Of course, all this changed once the economy started
going south. Companies that were once hungry for programmers
started becoming weary of body shoppers and middlemen. They
started questioning the need to employ a teaming workforce
just to keep their IT systems running. The tribe of body-shoppers
has all but vanished.
Incorporating
a private company in the US is an extremely straightforward
process. Given the risks involved in operating a business,
it is better to “incorporate” the business into a corporate
entity rather than operate as a sole proprietorship or partnership.
However, unlike India, where one has to move mountains before
one can incorporate a company, the process in the US (in
most states) is quite straightforward. All one needs to
do is to fill the necessary forms, which can be obtained
from the secretary of the state where one resides. After
filling the forms, one submits them along with the prescribed
fees and one is given a certificate to operate as a business
entity. The other paperwork like getting a tax id, opening
a bank account etc is equally simple and does not involve
a lot of paperwork. There are very few bureaucratic hurdles
one faces and the whole process of starting and operating
a small corporation is extremely streamlined. Incidentally,
US also allows foreign residents and temporary workers to
open operate corporate entities in the US. Any good corporate
attorney should be able to walk you through the innocuous
restrictions and bottlenecks. The result of all this is
that the process of forming a business entity is extremely
streamlined, leaving the entrepreneur to focus on the nitty-gritty
of running a business.
During
the dot.com boom, it was a universal dream to think of “killer
web-portals”. With very few barriers to entry, even half-baked
ideas were getting attention and capital. If there is any
good that has come out of the current dot.com crash (and
the economic downturn), it is that people are taking a hard
look at their business plans. They are looking at how their
business is making money, and are trying to become leaner
and meaner. Real good ideas and business models are only
going to survive and grow.
Thousands
of professionals who have built a rapport with their clients
operate as independent consultants (a.k.a. free agents).
Lawyers and financial analysts have long known that their
real allegiance is to the profession rather than individual
organizations. Being a corporate attorney or a corporate
financial analyst is less glamorous and paying than working
for a high profile partnership, or better still, for one’s
own firm. Doctors around the world have also relied on private
practice to provide the gravy, even if the bread and butter
come from working for a hospital. Academicians and professors
have refined moonlighting into an art, consulting for large
corporations by helping them understand and incorporate
the latest academic and research ideas, in the process raking
huge fees. Indians in the US are realizing that regardless
of the company they work for, they are not immune to the
vagaries of business, layoffs etc. Hence they strive to
get rewarded for the risks they take.
The
US economy may currently be going through a slow phase,
but the entrepreneurial spirit is still alive and kicking.
There are hundreds, if not thousands of Sanjiv Sidhu’s waiting
to exploit their killer ideas, announce IPO’s and strike
gold.
|